Books and Things 39K subscribers · Jun 10, 2024

Recent Interesting Historical Reads | The Walter Scott Prize Reviews #3

Reviews9

Liked

so overall like I did really enjoy absolutely and forever and like I said I think it does some really clever things towards the end of the novel it wasn't my favorite from the long list I'll talk a bit later on in the video about what books from the long list I would put on the short list and this probably wouldn't be one of them but I do think it is worth a read

Loved

I thought CI was incredible possibly my favorite book I've read this year amazing exploration of History amazingly moving powerful novel wonderful characterization wonderful use of form really inventive and original as well

Loved

I also feel like the characterization was great I really enjoyed the conversations between Cinder and the older woman I felt like their characterization was done so well and also the other characters around Cinder like the other people who live in the town of Dunmore you get such a good sense of their characters even if they're not in the narrative for that long it is a tough and emotional read but it has done so well and I really recommend it

Liked

I felt like the pacing at the end of my father's house was a little bit off and a little bit slow and like I feel like my father's house was a really great book and a really enjoyable reading experience but I feel like it was a bit flawed

Loved

of that short list my favorite to win is the New Life by Tom crew which I thought was fantastic I really loved it and I would be very happy to see it win the world Scot prize