Books and Things 39K subscribers · Jul 14, 2025

Recommending Elizabeth Gaskell to Jane Austen fans

Reviews11

Loved

One of my favorite things about Emma as a novel is the way it looks at small town society. and the way it looks at all the gossip and like insularess of a small town and I love the character of Miss Bates a lot.

Loved

I think Gascal's Gothic tales were all published separately in magazines during her lifetime, but Penguin have a bindup of what they call her Gothic tales which I listened to on audio book a few years ago as well as having read a lot of the stories separately many times. and it's a really great collection with a lot of really wonderful Gothic tales, really wonderful spooky happenings, ghost stories and strange occurrences and murder and disguise and escape.

Mixed

one I think is because Persuasion is probably the more serious somber of Jane Austin's books. , and Sylvia's Lovers is definitely one of Elizabeth Gaspull's more serious somber books, but also because these books have a sort of naval connection. , and look at the Napoleonic Wars.

Liked

The fondness between these two sisters and these two steps sisters and the differences between them and their difficulty in understanding each other like really has a lot in common and is the reason why I always think of these two books together.

Loved

Sylvia's Lovers is a wonderful, really powerful novel about a young woman torn between two men. one who she has known for a long time and who she likes but maybe she doesn't love and another man who she is falling for but maybe things aren't going to quite work out there. and it's such a powerful poignant novel and I feel like if you like the sort of like wisful sorrow of persuasion then I feel like you will really enjoy Sylvia's Lovers Too.

Loved

Wives and Daughters is a wonderful, beautiful coming of age story about a young girl called Molly Gibson, , and what happens when her father decides to remarry and a new stepmother and stepsister come into her life. It is a book about grief, about unrequited love, about growing up, , and about trying to understand the people around you. And I just I just love everything about it.