Becca and The Books 57K subscribers · Nov 8, 2025

My Patrons Picked What I Read for Shelve It or Scrap It Episode 12

Reviews24

Disliked

I am so turned off by the tone the setting and the atmosphere of this book that I am incredibly disinterested and even if something amazing happened in this book in the next 50 pages I'm kind of at the point where I wouldn't really care because it just doesn't really feel like it's for me

Disliked

I'm not invested and now that I'm kind of like less active cuz this is obviously taking up less I guess brain power than cleaning was I don't care enough about it to continue

Disliked

I am also genuinely devastated that I didn't like this book because I would have loved to have kept this Edition on my shelves forever this is so pretty but alas it is not to be

Disliked

I hated the twist in this I was like blew my mind and some of well most of Colleen Hoover's twists are not great but some are very entertaining this one just did not hit with me at all

Disliked

Mexican Gothic by Sylvia Marino Garcia which is a book that I ended up not really liking very much one because of the horror element that came into it like towards the end but also it just wasn't as creepy as I expected it to be

Liked

I always throw it back to Red risen where I almost dnfed up to like halfway through and then in the second half I ended up enjoying it and then the series has become like my favorite series of all time

Liked

I started off being like Oh I don't really feel any chemistry I don't really care about these characters and by the end I ended up loving this one I did give it four stars