Becca and The Books 57K subscribers · Sep 8, 2026

Episode 27 of Shelve It or Scrap It Really Couldn't have Gone Any Worse 😩

Reviews7

Liked

So I finished Silvercloak and I really enjoyed it right up until the end. I ended up giving this one four stars. And I think that the strength of this book is within the world which I found to be very immersive right from the very beginning, but also in the story which was very compelling.

Disliked

But something that I'm really struggling with this one is the writing style. Like, it is it's actually quite painful to me because it feels like the most basic, most average straight up young adult dystopian fantasy writing style. Like, I feel like I've read this a thousand times before.