Becca and The Books 57K subscribers Β· Aug 8, 2026

Random Number Generator Chooses What I Read for Shelve It or Scrap It Episode 26 πŸ“š

Reviews17

Disliked

Unfortunately, I'm here with some not great news because I have decided to DNF Dawn of the Firebird at around about I think it's not 50%, maybe around 40%, I'm on page 190. I made it over to chapter 17. Unfortunately, I feel like this has become less enjoyable in this section that I was the most excited about.

Liked

I decided not to pick up the Fairy Loot edition of the sequel to this because while I really enjoyed book one, I think I'm happy to pick up the sequel as a paperback or something, which means that I don't really need the first book, but I haven't like fully committed to that decision yet.

Loved

And I just read Human Rights by Juno Dawson, the last book in the Her Majesty's Royal Coven series. And one of my favorite things about that series is that the characters bear the scars of everything that's happened to them and it kind of like layers on top and makes them feel really fleshed out and one dimensional.

Disliked

But this also has elements of books that I didn't like the hurricane wars which I felt the world building in that was really poorly executed and I didn't care about the characters at all. So the entirety of that book was just a huge drag for me which unfortunately I'm kind of seeing similarities in the world in here and also my feelings regarding that.

Mixed

I felt like there was a real lull in the plot of the second book and I missed a lot of the like dynamic between characters that I really enjoyed in book one. And I felt like the direction that the world took or the ways in which we were developing the world wasn't as interesting because I didn't feel like it was building towards a point.

Disliked

I know specifically why I didn't like The Poppy War. I found a lot of inconsistencies. And the main character is a very reactive character and she makes a lot of decisions that are somebody who's very like logic driven and reasonable. I just couldn't get behind and she was really infuriating me.

Disliked

But I was really excited about that one, but I felt like it focused more on the romance, which I didn't realize was going to be part of that book, than it did on this witch going to look after three young witches who didn't have any guidance. And then I felt like the romance was really out of place and distracted from what I thought the book was actually about, given what the synopsis says the book is about.