Becca and The Books 57K subscribers · Nov 8, 2024

Every Series I Read In 2023 📚 DNFs, Completed & In Progress

Reviews25

Disliked

now I was kind of getting swept away with the Vibes of the romance up until I got to the end and I felt like a really important plot point was shoehorned in and rushed just for the sake of like having something to launch the second book of and I decided that this was it for me and I just didn't I wasn't interested in continuing on

Loved

the thing that I really loved about this is while we're pursuing this plot we are also getting a lot of hints towards a larger plot that we are assumably going to be exploring later in the series and I honestly cannot wait

Disliked

but ultimately it kind of just the longer it went on I never really grew more attached to the characters and it lost my interest quite quickly and really disappointed about this one but yeah I just I won't be continuing

Loved

I thought that it was very well done very reminiscent in its like I guess balance between the history and the fantasy elements like the winternight trilogy and also providing a very rich like well-developed fantasy world like city of brasas so would definitely recommend this one

Disliked

I found this to be very unengaging it was pretty much in one ear out the other I didn't retain anything that happened in here and on paper everything in this book is something that I should enjoy but something just didn't come together in the execution for me and this one actually made my worst books of the year list

Disliked

it's the wild west element of this that I don't enjoy and I also really don't like the humor I'm not a massive fan of wax or Wayne either although they do get a little bit better or the story at least gets a little bit better in book two

Disliked

my main issue with this one is that it kind of felt like every other Ry cman story that I'd read but also that while the puzzle setup of this is interesting the way that it was presented wasn't in a way where the reader can really get engaged in the puzzle so it was kind of just like watching other people solve puzzles which isn't the most fun