Andrew’s Wizardly Reads 13.4K subscribers · Jun 13, 2025

Decluttering My Bookshelves: 28 Fantasy Books Removed

Reviews14

Mixed

And here, I was really vibing with the characters, and I was vibing with the world, and I was vibing with everything about this book. And it like Raymond Eyee Feice is just amazing except there's just there's a sexual assault scene within this book that I just don't think was handled particularly well. It hasn't aged particularly well.

Disliked

Like it doesn't really resolve anything. And I just felt like the journey wasn't worth the destination on this one. despite the fact that like some great characterization, some great moments, really cool premise, but this one just was a failure to land for me.

Disliked

It's a western fantasy and overall like it seems like a good premise but the execution just isn't pulling me in. and I'm not vibing with the characters and I wanted to like Mary Goodcrow, but like when you first meet Gary when you first meet Mary Goodcrowah, Mary is like really cool and she's like escaping and she's got all these powers and it's really awesome. And then the next time you see her, not so much.