A Critical Dragon 12K subscribers · Mar 1, 2021

Chat with Ian C Esslemont about Malazan (Spoiler Free)

Reviews3

Liked

like at the very beginning of dancer's lament obviously that scene and that sequence of him going through into that tunnel and then it's the surprise moment there and i just it's played for humor but also works intrinsically within the narrative and the horror element as well

Loved

here was a novel that had all of the appearance trappings and feel of a solid action-packed fantasy novel and yet it all occurs in the time frame of one night the night of knives and to mine to my knowledge and i could be mistaken on this but i can't think of any other fantasy novel where everything happens in a single night and the fact that you managed to pull that off and pull it off convincingly i just i looked at that and went i've never a never seen it before and was just really impressed

Mixed

he's done this brilliant structuring of the society of werewolves and how they organize themselves and how they organize their sort of hierarchies but they all have werewolf names which are all lupine sounds so as a reader i am looking at these 23 letter long just gibberish going i can't you and i called susan and i literally renamed all of the characters because i couldn't hear their name in my head because they were all lupine sounds and i think that takes that very similitude and that authenticity just that slightly too far because it is still meant to be a novel