I enjoyed some things about I didn't feel that it was perfect the author died sort of part the way through and while it has been finished off and I really liked the ending I feel like the first half of the book would have been probably more developed if the author hadn't passed away and so I did enjoy it but I feel like there were also other things that I wanted to know about all I didn't feel we really explored that much so I enjoyed it was a fairly interesting read and nice and festive